Kasia Dietz
Updated on: October 11, 2024 8:01 pm GMT
Costs for the iconic bearskin caps worn by the King’s Guard have jumped significantly, now exceeding £2,000 each. Figures released by the Ministry of Defence (MoD) reveal a sharp increase in expenditure, prompting animal rights activists to argue that switching to faux fur is both financially and ethically justified.
Soaring Costs Revealed
The expenditures related to bearskin caps have experienced a dramatic shift in the past year. According to data obtained through a Freedom of Information request, the price of each bearskin cap has surged by 30%, rising from £1,560 in 2022 to £2,040 in 2023. Over the past decade, total spending on these caps exceeds £1 million.
- 2022 Cost: £1,560 (approximately $2,040)
- 2023 Cost: £2,040 (approximately $2,670)
- Expenditure Over the Last Decade: More than £1 million (approximately $1.3 million)
This increase has drawn the ire of animal welfare organizations like People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), which advocates for an end to the use of real fur in military uniforms.
PETA’s Criticism
PETA has consistently voiced concerns over the use of real fur, labeling it as both unethical and financially burdensome. Elisa Allen, a representative from PETA, stated, “Stop wasting taxpayer pounds on caps made from slaughtered wildlife, and switch to faux fur today.” The organization argues that:
- Animal Cruelty: The hunting methods for black bears, which include potential use of crossbows, may result in prolonged suffering for the animals.
- Waste of Taxpayer Money: A recent survey indicated that about 75% of UK residents believe the use of real bearskin caps is an unnecessary expenditure for the public purse.
Allen further noted that with the rising costs and ethical concerns, it is crucial for the MoD to reconsider its procurement strategies.
Government’s Stance on Alternatives
The MoD has acknowledged the rising costs and the growing skepticism around the use of real bear fur. A spokesperson indicated that the ministry is “open to exploring faux fur alternatives” but stressed that any potential replacements must meet specific requirements related to safety and durability. These criteria include tests for:
- Water absorption
- Penetration
- Appearance
- Drying rate
- Compression
To date, no alternative materials have met all five tests. Despite this, the MoD has expressed a willingness to review samples of faux fur materials if they can satisfy these standards.
Current Practices of the MoD
The Ministry of Defence sources the fur used for the caps from licensed hunts in Canada. They emphasize that bears are not hunted specifically for these caps; rather, the fur is acquired through regulated practices. The MoD maintains that they engage in a sustainable approach to furs, despite the contentious nature of the hunting tactics employed.
- Bear Sourcing: The MoD states that all fur is sourced from legal, licensed hunts in Canada.
- Caps Procurement: In 2023, the MoD reported that 24 new caps were purchased, following the acquisition of 13 caps in 2022.
Historical and Cultural Significance
The bearskin caps, characterized by their tall stature and unique appearance, are a long-standing tradition in British military ceremonial dress. They are prominently featured during events such as Trooping the Colour. Advocates of maintaining the use of real fur argue that the caps are durable and uphold the standards required for such ceremonial occasions.
In light of the controversies, some officials, including former Labour shadow minister for defense Stephanie Peacock, have called for an immediate review of potential alternatives to bear fur. Peacock has emphasized the importance of evolving traditions to align with contemporary values.
Royal Influence on Fur Sourcing
While the decision about fur usage lies with the MoD, insights from the royal family have recently added another layer to the narrative. Queen Camilla has publicly shifted her preferences, declaring she would no longer purchase new fur garments, indicating a possible move towards a more ethical approach in line with public sentiment.
The Path Forward
Despite promises to explore faux fur options, the debate over the bearskin caps continues, highlighting a broader conversation about traditions, ethics, and financial responsibilities. The MoD remains open to re-evaluating the use of real fur, particularly as pressure mounts from animal welfare groups and shifting public opinion.
As people talk more about the bearskin caps, new rules or changes in how they are bought might change their future. There is a struggle between keeping old traditions and following today’s ethical standards, and this will be an important part of the conversation.
