David PowellUpdated on: October 12, 2024 5:59 am GMT
As the trial of Carly Madison Gregg, a 15-year-old from Rankin County, begins this week, the courtroom is set to hear harrowing details surrounding the alleged murder of her mother, Ashley Smylie, and the attempted murder of her stepfather, Heath Smylie. The tragic events that unfolded in March have left a community and a family grappling with unimaginable grief and questions.
Case Background
Carly Gregg stands accused of fatally shooting her mother and injuring her stepfather at their home in Brandon. At the time of the incident, Carly was just 14 years old. She now faces serious charges including first-degree murder, attempted murder, and tampering with evidence as she stands trial as an adult.
Key details leading up to the trial include:
- Date of Incident: March
- Charges Filed: First-degree murder, attempted murder, and tampering with evidence
- Current Age of Defendant: 15 years old
- Trial Start Date: September 16
- Presiding Judge: Dewey Arthur
- Potential Sentence: 20 years to life if convicted
Insights from the Prosecution
Prosecutors have laid out their case during the trial, indicating they will introduce evidence that paints a picture of Gregg’s “secret life.” This includes claims that she had a hidden boyfriend, a secret phone, and struggles with self-harm.
Prosecutor Kathryn Newman emphasized the severity of the situation, stating that
“Gregg shot her stepfather, who then called 911 and said, ‘She’s killed her mother. She’s run off.'”
Newman added that DNA evidence on the firearm, a .357 Magnum, matched Gregg’s DNA.
A crucial moment in the prosecution’s argument is the chilling allegation that Gregg had shown the body of her deceased mother to a friend shortly after the shooting. This friend reportedly was asked whether she was “squeamish around dead bodies,” a claim that defense attorney Bridgett Todd challenged as being embellished.
Defense’s Position
On the other side of the courtroom, defense attorney Bridgett Todd plans to counter the prosecution’s narrative by illustrating Carly’s close bond with her mother. Todd argues that Carly was a good student and loved her mother deeply. During opening statements, she mentioned:
“Heath Smylie believes Gregg didn’t recognize him when he came home and was terrified.”
The defense intends to delve into the mental health struggles that Carly reportedly faced. They will argue that evidence exists showing that Carly and her mother were concerned about a possible hereditary mental illness, as her father had previously battled such issues.
“I want the jury to understand that Carly was receiving psychological help leading up to this incident,” Todd explained.
Furthermore, the defense will point out that Carly’s medications had changed shortly before the incident, an important aspect they believe could provide insight into her state of mind during the shooting.
Witness Testimonies and Evidence
The trial commenced with the first witness, Kevin Collins, a dispatcher for the Rankin County Sheriff’s Department. Collins recounted receiving a frantic 911 call from Heath Smylie, who was crying and in distress.
>
- Heath’s Descriptions during the Call:
– “Carly tried to kill him.”
– “She has killed her mother.”
Prosecutors showcased a report from an investigator claiming Carly fired multiple times at her mother following an argument over personal items taken from her bedroom.
During her opening statements, Todd warned the jury about accepting witness accounts without skepticism and reminded them that the tragic event was influenced by complex emotional turmoil within the family.
Carly Gregg’s Future
As Carly Gregg sits in solitary confinement at Rankin County Jail, the gravity of her situation weighs heavily. Since rejecting a plea deal that would have resulted in a 40-year sentence, she now faces the implications of a trial that could alter the course of her life forever.
This trial is not only a legal procedure but also a reflection of a deep family tragedy that has shocked the community. The outcome will undoubtedly have lasting effects on those involved.
Conclusion
Carly Gregg’s trial will take place over several days. During this time, both sides will share their stories, and the jury will carefully look at all the details of the case. The community is watching closely, hoping for justice for Ashley Smylie and a fair look at Carly’s choices and situation. The jury’s decision could affect Carly’s life and remind everyone about the challenges of mental health in families.
