Noah Rosenstein
Updated on: October 10, 2024 5:46 pm GMT
Michael Lombardi Sounds Off on Giants’ Struggles and GM Joe Schoen’s Decisions
Former NFL executive Michael Lombardi has not held back in his criticism of the New York Giants, particularly targeting general manager Joe Schoen after the team’s disheartening 28-6 loss to the Minnesota Vikings on Sunday. On this week’s episode of “The GM Shuffle” podcast, Lombardi expressed his disappointment over the Giants’ current trajectory and the lack of effective leadership in the organization.
Lombardi’s Critique of Team Performance
Lombardi, who previously served as the general manager of the Cleveland Browns and director of pro personnel for the Philadelphia Eagles, has been a vocal critic of Schoen for some time. Following the Giants’ loss, he pointed to the team’s overall lack of cohesion and strategic planning. “When you watch that, there were no models, there was no, ‘How are we building this team?’ It was really amateur hour,” he remarked. Lombardi believes the current state of the team is actually embarrassing for all involved and reflects poorly on the sports industry.
Fan Discontent and Team Morale
Lombardi contends that the discontent among Giants fans is palpable, asserting that they have lost confidence in Schoen’s leadership. “I feel bad for the Giants fans. I really do because I don’t see how it gets better,” he said. His observations resonate with many in the fandom who feel stuck in a pattern of frustration and disappointment.
The Coaching Conundrum
While Lombardi offered praise for head coach Brian Daboll, he was quick to assert that even the best coaching can’t rescue a team suffering from poor construction and poor decisions made by upper management. He emphasized that ”you can’t make chicken salad out of chicken s—,” showcasing his doubts that any coach can achieve success with a flawed roster.
Issues Highlighted After the Vikings Game
In the Giants’ recent game against the Vikings, Lombardi pointed out specific moments that illustrated the team’s struggles. He noted that their secondary was “one of the worst in football,” pointing to their inability to contain Vikings quarterback Sam Darnold, who completed an impressive percentage of his passes. Lombardi’s assessment doesn’t stop at the defense; he also raised concerns about quarterback Daniel Jones’ performance, calling him “skittish” and “flustered,” making it untenable to expect improvement under the current circumstances.
Quarterback Dilemma
The Giants’ quarterback situation remains a hot topic. Lombardi suggested that the franchise might need to consider benching Jones, particularly if improvements are not seen in the near future. “I don’t think the Giants players buy into that they think they’re gonna win,” Lombardi said, arguing that a poor offensive line and ineffective playmakers are contributing factors to the team’s woes.
Future Implications for the Giants
The implications of the Giants’ current state stretch into next season. Lombardi warned that if the organization doesn’t take significant steps to redefine its approach, the team could find itself selecting at the top of the draft again, needing to rebuild once more.
Recent Developments and the Road Ahead
Since the loss to the Vikings, speculation around potential changes in the Giants’ organization has increased. Many analysts and fans believe a turning point could be on the horizon; some wonder if Schoen will consider shaking up his coaching staff or re-evaluating the roster. The upcoming game against the Washington Commanders looms large, especially for Jones, who remains under scrutiny.
If All Else Fails
As the Giants prepare to face Washington, the pressure on the team’s leaders intensifies. Should they fail to show marked improvement, it could lead to critical decisions regarding both Schoen and Daboll. Given the team’s trajectory, Lombardi’s commentary raises an essential question: How much longer can the Giants rely on the current formula before significant changes are necessary?
Fan Outlook
The Giants’ fan base is both anxious and hopeful. Many are tuning in despite frustrations, yearning for a turnaround that seems elusive. As discussions heat up about possible adjustments, the coming weeks could prove decisive for the future of the franchise.
Conclusion
The New York Giants are at a tough spot right now. They are dealing with problems caused by weak leadership and not knowing where to go next. Lombardi’s sharp comments remind everyone, from fans to team leaders, that it might be time for a change. We’re not sure if Schoen and Daboll can turn things around, but even the most hopeful fans are starting to get ready for another rebuilding phase.
