Noah Rosenstein
Updated on: October 13, 2024 1:31 am GMT
Jamie Carragher Chooses His All-Time Liverpool XI, Sparking Debate
Jamie Carragher, an iconic figure in Liverpool Football Club’s history, has unveiled his all-time Liverpool XI, stirring discussion among fans and pundits alike. The former defender selected just two of his ex-teammates and included two current players, highlighting the competition and talent that has graced Anfield over the years.
Carragher, who played for Liverpool from 1997 to 2013, made his picks during the “Stick to Football” podcast. In total, he named a squad that showcases not only his personal connections but also a deep respect for the club’s storied legacy.
Key Selections
Carragher kicked off his lineup with goalkeeper Ray Clemence, preferring him over current star Alisson Becker. Clemence, who was instrumental in winning multiple titles with the Reds, received praise for his trophy-laden career. Carragher stated, “I would go with Ray Clemence just over Alisson, just for the fact he won so many trophies.”
- Goalkeeper: Ray Clemence
- Right Back: Phil Neal
- Centre Backs: Alan Hansen, Virgil Van Dijk
- Left Back: Steve Nicol
Alongside Clemence, Carragher chose Phil Neal at right back, citing Neal’s remarkable achievement of winning four European Cups, which positioned him ahead of current player Trent Alexander-Arnold. For left back, Carragher opted for the versatile Steve Nicol instead of Andy Robertson, indicating that Liverpool has historically faced challenges in that position.
Midfield Mastery
The midfield section of Carragher’s all-time XI features two renowned players, Steven Gerrard and Graeme Souness, noted for their leadership and contributions to Liverpool’s success.
- Midfield: Mo Salah, Graeme Souness, Steven Gerrard, John Barnes
John Barnes was acknowledged for his technical excellence, with Carragher previously labeling him as the best player he had ever trained with. He remarked, “Technically, he’s the best player I’ve ever trained or played with,” further emphasizing Barnes’s impact during his tenure at Anfield.
Carragher made room for Mo Salah, the Egyptian forward who has become a fan favorite, alongside Gerrard and Souness. “Graeme Souness has to be in central midfield alongside Steven Gerrard,” Carragher noted. The addition of Salah reflects the forward’s significant impact at Liverpool.
Dynamic Attack
Completing Carragher’s striking trio was the legendary pair of Kenny Dalglish and Ian Rush, two players synonymous with Liverpool’s successes in the 1980s.
- Forwards: Kenny Dalglish, Ian Rush
Dalglish’s astute football intelligence and Rush’s knack for scoring goals solidified their places in Carragher’s lineup. The former Liverpool defender reflected on Rush’s prowess, recalling how the striker’s goals against Everton brought him to tears as a young supporter of the rival club.
Carragher expressed, “If Luis Suárez would have won the league with Liverpool – he won one trophy. If he had a league title and a European Cup to his name, I would have put Suárez in.” This comment showcases the weight Carragher places on team success when evaluating players.
Notable Omissions
Carragher’s all-time selection raises eyebrows not only for the players included but also for those overlooked. His chosen lineup doesn’t feature significant names like Fernando Torres, Luis Suárez, or even Ian Callaghan.
The exclusion of such players highlights the fierce competition within Liverpool’s history and Carragher’s personal bias towards players who resonate with the club’s successful eras.
In further discussions, fans have debated the validity of Carragher’s selections, questioning why certain players did not make the list. This discourse reflects the passion Liverpool supporters have for their club legends.
Conclusion
Jamie Carragher’s all-time Liverpool XI is a personal testament to his experiences and connections formed during his years at Anfield. With a blend of past and present talent, his choices have sparked meaningful conversations among fans. While there will always be differing opinions on the best lineup, Carragher’s selections capture the essence of Liverpool’s rich footballing history and the players who left an indelible mark on its journey.
Liverpool is building its history, and Carragher’s choices show us how special this club is. If you want to hear Carragher talk more about his lineup, check out the “Stick to Football” podcast for the full discussion.
