Margaret Chrystall
Updated on: October 11, 2024 6:57 pm GMT
Netflix’s latest release, “Uglies,” is a cinematic adaptation of Scott Westerfeld’s popular dystopian YA novel series, now attempting to carve its own space within a genre that has faded from the limelight in recent years. Released on the streaming service in 2024, this film aims to reignite interest in young adult dystopian narratives, but early reviews suggest it may not achieve that goal.
Plot Overview
Set in a future where beauty is mandated by government-sanctioned plastic surgery, “Uglies” follows Tally Youngblood, played by Joey King, as she navigates a society obsessed with perfection. In this world, individuals undergo a transformative procedure at the age of sixteen to eliminate all physical flaws, evolving from “Uglies” to “Pretties.” As Tally waits for her turn, she grapples with her feelings for her best friend, Peris (Chase Stokes), and is drawn into a rebellion against the beauty standard embodied by elite society.
From Friendship to Rebellion
The film quickly establishes the bond between Tally and Peris, setting up their promise to stay true to each other amid the societal pressure to conform to beauty ideals. However, when Peris undergoes the transformation, he returns with a new, distant persona, prompting Tally to seek answers. She meets Shay (Brianne Tju), another “Ugly” who rejects the surgery and seeks a life in freedom with a group known as “The Smoke.” As circumstances unfold, Tally is faced with a choice: stay within her comfort zone and undergo the procedure, or risk everything for authenticity and personal truth.
Directorial and Screenwriting Choices
Directed by McG, known for his work on “Charlie’s Angels” and “The Babysitter,” “Uglies” struggles to find a unique voice among its contemporaries. The screenplay, co-written by Vanessa Taylor and others, attempts to touch upon important themes surrounding beauty standards and individuality. However, critics have pointed out that the execution feels lacking depth and originality, offering clichéd ideas that fail to resonate profoundly with the audience.
The Aesthetic and Production Elements
The film’s visual design has received mixed reviews. While it aims for a vibrant and futuristic aesthetic using extensive CGI, critics argue that the execution feels overly artificial, not effectively contributing to the overall storytelling. The contrast between the colorful façade of the capital and the grim realities of life outside provides a surface-level commentary on societal stratification, yet it lacks substance in its presentation. Many reviewers noted that the production design ultimately feels like “CGI fireworks” without delivering a strong visual narrative.
Character Development and Performances
Joey King’s portrayal of Tally provides a glimpse of earnestness within a narrative riddled with flaws. Though she attempts to bring complexity to her character, reviews indicate that the script does not support her efforts adequately. The character’s rapid mood swings and decisions, based on plot conveniences rather than genuine development, detract from her depth. Chase Stokes as Peris, while visually suitable for his role, faces criticism for the implausibility of portraying a sixteen-year-old, given his actual age of 31.
The Message of the Film
“Uglies” centers around the theme of beauty versus authenticity, encouraging viewers to question societal norms regarding physical appearance. However, critics argue that while the film ostensibly promotes self-acceptance and individuality, it fails to provide a sincere dialogue on what it means to embrace one’s identity. The disjointed elements of the plot and characterization undermine its messages, leaving audiences with an impression of superficiality.
Critical Reception and Audience Takeaways
The initial reception of “Uglies” has been lukewarm at best. Critics have labeled the film as one of the more forgettable new releases of 2024, citing its heavy reliance on tired tropes common in earlier dystopian narratives. The combination of subpar dialogue, lack of engaging character arcs, and uninspired visual elements contributes to a viewing experience that feels more obligatory than innovative.
Comparative Context
The film arrives at a time when the YA dystopian genre has significantly waned since its peak, marked by successes such as “The Hunger Games” and “Divergent.” With many successful adaptations now considered cultural touchstones, “Uglies” finds itself competing against high expectations but seems unable to deliver a fresh take or rekindle a sense of urgency in the genre.
Final Thoughts
As “Uglies” becomes available on Netflix, people are wondering if this movie will connect with today’s viewers or if it will be forgotten like other young adult films. The story talks about important ideas about beauty and how society sees it, but it might not make a strong impact. If you’re interested in themes of beauty and identity, there might be better movies in this genre to watch.
