Amber Phillips
Updated on: October 11, 2024 6:01 pm GMT
Pope Francis has urged American Catholics to navigate the complexities of the upcoming U.S. presidential election by choosing what he describes as the “lesser evil.” Speaking during a press conference on his return flight from a recent tour in Asia, the Pope pointedly criticized both Republican nominee Donald Trump and Democratic nominee Kamala Harris for their respective policies on abortion and migration, stating that both candidates are “against life.”
Pope’s Critique of Key Candidates
In his remarks, Pope Francis did not directly name either candidate but articulated a clear stance on what he perceives as anti-life policies associated with each. He argued that the actions of both candidates contradict fundamental Catholic teachings. “Both are against life,” he stated, referring to Trump’s immigration policies and Harris’s support for abortion rights. He emphasized that American voters, particularly Catholics, should reflect on their choices, stressing the importance of voting with a sense of moral responsibility.
Voting with Conscience
During the in-flight press conference, Pope Francis underscored the significance of civic engagement, saying that abstaining from voting is “bad.” He urged Catholics to engage thoughtfully in the electoral process, stating, “You have to vote, and you have to choose the lesser evil.” This guidance reflects the longstanding Catholic teaching that in circumstances where no candidate fully aligns with the Church’s values, voting against the candidate who would cause the most harm is permissible.
Focus on Abortion and Migration
Pope Francis has been vocal about the issues of abortion and migration throughout his papacy. He reiterated his firm belief that abortion constitutes the killing of a human being, declaring, “To have an abortion is to kill a human being.” He emphasized that the Church’s stance against abortion is grounded in the belief that it represents a grave moral failing. The Pope cited scientific consensus, noting that a month after conception, all organs of a human being are present.
On the subject of migration, the Pope argued that it is a fundamental human right as described in scripture. He urged believers to heed the Biblical call to welcome strangers and warned that ignoring this directive amounts to committing a “grave sin.” His comments resonate with his earlier statements regarding immigration policies and humanitarian treatment of migrants.
Context of the Comments
Pope Francis’s comments come at a time of heightened political tensions in the U.S., particularly surrounding issues related to abortion and migration, which were significant topics in the recent presidential debate. His remarks are consistent with the U.S. bishops’ conference position, which has labeled abortion as the “preeminent priority” for American Catholics in matters of voting guidance.
The Pope’s intervention is notable given the traditional reticence of popes to engage in the political arena, particularly concerning U.S. elections. However, Francis has a history of making impassioned statements on political matters, indicating a commitment to addressing key moral issues that impact society.
A Legacy of Bold Statements
Pope Francis has made headlines throughout his 11-year papacy with remarks on a range of topics, often prioritizing inclusion and compassion. His willingness to address contentious issues, including LGBTQ+ rights, climate change, and economic inequality, showcases a modern approach to leadership within the Catholic Church. Some of his previous significant comments include:
- During his first press conference in 2013, he famously stated, “Who am I to judge?” when asked about a gay priest.
- In 2016, he criticized the notion of building walls to block migrants, asserting such actions are “not Christian.”
- More recently, he has articulated the tensions of morality and modernity, indicating that while the Church does not condone homosexual acts, it does offer love and acceptance to LGBTQ+ individuals.
These statements reflect a broader attempt to engage with contemporary issues while also maintaining fidelity to Catholic doctrine.
The Road Ahead
As the 2024 presidential election approaches, the ramifications of Pope Francis’s comments may influence the decisions of Catholic voters. His identification of the candidates’ policies as contrary to Church teaching places additional pressure on believers to reflect deeply on their electoral choices. As discussions around abortion and immigration continue to dominate the political landscape, the Pope’s guidance serves as a reminder of the moral complexities that accompany the democratic process.
Pope Francis’s calls for thoughtful engagement in the electoral process emphasize the need for voters to carefully consider the impact of their choices not only on fellow citizens but also in relation to their faith. His objective remains focused on promoting a culture that values life and compassion, principles central to Catholic social teaching.
As American voters get ready for the elections in November, the Pope is reminding everyone to think about how their political choices match their personal and religious beliefs. This message might influence how people in the Church and its followers talk about the election.
