Emily Zemler
Updated on: October 10, 2024 7:04 pm GMT
The latest adaptation of Scott Westerfeld’s popular Young Adult series, “Uglies,” has arrived on Netflix but has failed to make a significant impact with audiences, garnering criticism for its execution and underlying themes. With Joey King in the lead role of Tally, the film attempts to tackle complex issues surrounding beauty standards and societal pressures but falls short, leaving viewers questioning its purpose.
Plot Overview and Main Characters
“Uglies” is set in a dystopian future where humanity has resorted to drastic measures to eliminate conflict, including the implementation of eugenics and a rigid caste system. The film follows Tally, a 15-year-old girl who eagerly awaits her 16th birthday, the day when she will undergo radical cosmetic surgery to become a “Pretty.” Played by Joey King, Tally navigates this oppressive world while dealing with her relationships, particularly with her friend Peris (Chase Stokes), who undergoes the surgery and quickly forgets about her.
After losing her friend, Tally befriends Shay (Brianne Tju), an adventurous character who introduces her to a resistance group called “The Smoke.” However, Tally’s aspirations to join the group are complicated by Dr. Cable (Laverne Cox), the film’s antagonist, who demands Tally betray this new friendship to secure her own transformation.
Characterization and Themes
A notable criticism of “Uglies” centers on its character portrayal. The film presents a cast of conventionally attractive individuals labeled as “ugly,” which diminishes the potential commentary on beauty standards it seeks to make. Critics argue that the absence of characters who genuinely embody unconventional beauty weakens the narrative’s authenticity. Furthermore, the film’s depiction of Dr. Cable has been viewed as problematic, as it portrays a beautiful trans woman as a dictatorial figure, raising concerns about reinforcing harmful stereotypes.
Visual and Narrative Execution
In addition to its characterization issues, the film’s visual presentation has been described as uninspired. With generic set designs featuring brutalist architecture and lifeless landscapes, the film fails to create a distinctive or engaging visual aesthetic. Reviewers have noted that this lack of visual flair contributes to the overall feeling of boredom while watching.
Reception and Critique
The reception of “Uglies” has generally leaned towards the negative, with many critics pinning its shortcomings on a lackluster script and execution. The film’s attempts to address significant societal issues such as beauty and self-worth have been perceived as muddled and poorly realized. Instead of providing a thoughtful critique of societal standards, it has been viewed as reinforcing harmful norms, particularly through its treatment of beauty and conformity.
Conclusion
“Uglies” presents a missed opportunity to inspire meaningful discussions surrounding personal identity and societal expectations. While it seeks to deliver a cautionary tale about the dangers of conforming to superficial standards, its execution leaves much to be desired. As the film stands, it appears to have sacrificed depth and nuance for a narrative that ultimately fails to resonate with audiences. Viewers interested in themes of identity and societal structures may seek more fulfilling alternatives within the genre.
Sorry, but I can’t provide that information.
